How Brand Values Can Guide Better Marketing Decisions

Your organization has values. But when a real marketing decision comes up, knowing what those values mean in practice isn’t always so obvious.

How should they influence the message you choose, the audience experience you create or the partners you work with? And how do you use them as a guide without trying to force every marketing decision through a values lens?

There isn’t a perfect formula. But there are practical ways to make your values more useful when decisions come up.

Here are a few places to start.

Start by Defining and Clarifying Your Values

Words like “community,” “authenticity” and “inclusion” can mean a lot of different things. Simply naming a value doesn’t tell your team what to do with it.

For values to be useful, they need to provide some direction when you’re making real decisions. Harvard Business School Online makes a similar point in its guidance on implementing core values, noting that effective values should help people navigate tough decisions, not just give an organization something nice to put on paper.

For marketers, that means translating each value into tangible behaviours or decision-making principles that can guide creative work, content, partnerships and other marketing choices.

A few questions can help:

• What would this value change about the way we work?
• What choices would it encourage us to make?
• What might we do differently if we really committed to it?
• Is there anything we’d stop doing?

The goal is to get specific enough that your values can help you make decisions.

Use Values as Daily Decision Filters

Once you’ve defined what your values mean in practice, they can become useful questions to bring into everyday marketing decisions.

That doesn’t mean finding a way to connect every decision back to a value. It means having a shared framework for the moments when your values really do matter.

When you’re reviewing a campaign brief, creative direction, partnership or message, you might ask:

• Does this choice reflect what we’ve said is important to us?
• Who benefits from this decision?
• Who might be left out?
• Are we communicating honestly about what we’re offering?
• Is there a better way to approach this that feels more aligned with what we believe?

Sometimes those questions will confirm that you’re heading in the right direction. Sometimes they’ll uncover something worth reconsidering. Both outcomes are useful.

Look at How Your Values Show Up in the Audience Experience

Values aren’t only communicated through what a brand says. They can also show up in what people actually experience.

That might mean the stories you choose to tell, the channels you use, how accessible an experience is or whether your messaging acknowledges what your audience is really dealing with.

We’ve seen this in our work with clients, where understanding what an audience is experiencing has shaped both the messages we share and the stories we use to tell them:

• Addressing what people are really concerned about: For Penn College Workforce Development’s Weather the Future campaign, the challenge called for messaging that acknowledged the realities of the work while speaking to different audiences in relevant ways. It’s a useful example of what can happen when a marketing team asks what its audience actually needs to hear rather than starting with the easiest message to promote.
• Telling stories people can relate to: In our work with Tourism HR Canada, storytelling helped make the campaign relatable to people considering careers in tourism. Rather than simply telling audiences what the sector offered, the campaign found a more human way to communicate it.

These examples aren’t a universal formula for values-based marketing. They do show how paying closer attention to your audience can lead to more thoughtful choices about what you say and how you say it.

Adapt Values to Your Audience’s Needs and Challenges

Values can stay consistent while the way you put them into practice changes.

Your audience brings real experiences, concerns and barriers to every interaction with your brand. Economic pressures, cultural context, accessibility, scepticism and changing circumstances can all affect how a message or experience lands.

That makes audience understanding an important part of values-based marketing.

Try asking:

• How might this value show up for this particular audience?
• Is there a gap between what we intend and what someone might experience?
• What barriers could make it harder for people to participate?
• Are we communicating this value in a way that’s actually relevant here?

This isn’t about changing your values to suit every audience. It’s about understanding that the same value might need to show up differently depending on the context.

If accessibility matters to your organization, for example, that might shape how you design a digital experience, choose a venue or share information in different formats. If honesty matters, it might influence how directly you address the challenges or limitations your audience is likely to encounter.

Your values provide the direction. Your audience helps you understand what that direction needs to look like in practice.

Make Values Part of the Creative Process

Values are easier to act on when they become part of the process rather than something you check at the end.

That could mean adding a few values-based questions to your campaign brief. It could mean discussing them during creative reviews or using them when you’re choosing collaborators and partners.

You don’t necessarily need another complicated framework.

A few useful prompts might be enough:

• What value is most relevant to this project?
• What would that value look like in the final experience?
• Is anything we’re proposing in tension with it?
• What could we change to bring the work closer to our intentions?

Bringing those questions into the process early gives your team more room to act on the answers.

Measure Whether People Are Experiencing Your Values

If values influence how you market, they can also influence how you think about success.

Reach, impressions, clicks and website visits can all be useful. But depending on what you’re trying to accomplish, they may not tell you whether people experienced what you hoped they would.

If community is important, you might pay attention to participation and whether people are building connections. If trust matters, feedback and sentiment might tell you something useful. If inclusion is a priority, you might look at who is participating, whose perspectives are represented and whether barriers remain.

The right measures will depend on the value, the audience and the campaign. You don’t necessarily need to replace your usual marketing metrics. Instead, think about what you could measure alongside them to better understand whether your values are showing up in the audience experience.

A useful question to ask is: What would we expect to see, hear or learn if people were actually experiencing this value?

The answer can help you choose measures that connect what your organization values with what your audience experiences.

Wrapping Up

Turning brand values into marketing decisions doesn’t require a perfect formula.

It starts by getting specific about what your values mean, then asking better questions when you’re making choices about audiences, creative work, partnerships, channels and measurement.

Sometimes a value will clearly point you toward one choice over another. Other times, it might simply help your team notice a tension you hadn’t considered before. That’s still useful.

The goal isn’t to make every marketing decision prove how values-driven your brand is. It’s to make sure the values you’ve chosen have a meaningful role in how you work.

FAQ