Published On: January 25, 2021By
Spruce Up Your Story logo

When working with Red River Mutual to redefine their company values and reinvigorate their brand in 2018, we helped them introduce a new look and a new tagline: Your Story is Ours to Protect.

This tagline not only became a rallying cry for their internal staff to celebrate what’s unique about their purpose, it also became the driving force behind all of their strategic marketing initiatives – aiming to convey this authentic regard for their communities’ wellbeing.

As a mutual insurance company, Red River Mutual’s whole purpose is to serve the community it protects. And, while in its 145 years, it has always been a generous, philanthropic company (beyond providing coverage for your home, farm and business), their marketing team decided that in 2019, they would consolidate their sponsorship efforts into their own, wider submission-driven initiative.

Understanding the Challenge

While identifying the need for a concerted community sponsorship effort, their initial budget allocated for the campaign in its inaugural year didn’t allow for a large-scale community development project, such as building a new playground, but it did allow for multiple smaller-scale projects. Since Red River Mutual primarily protects small-town communities, where a recreation centre or garden can be the lifeblood of a town, it became clear that awarding funds to cover multiple restoration projects, to help repair and preserve places that people cherished, would be the best approach.

Finding the Concept

We knew we wanted to connect the community sponsorship campaign to the larger brand message: Your Story is Ours to Protect, but we also wanted to ensure the brand made it clear that this was not some multi-million dollar capital funding initiative – rather, it was a homegrown company offering to help communities keep the important gathering places in their communities going.


The result? Spruce Up Your Story – an initiative that would help your beloved community spaces go from “rusted to restored”; “broken to beautiful” or “wrecked to renewed.”

Everyone loves a good makeover story – and there are hundreds of community spaces across Manitoba and Saskatchewan in need of a pick-me-up— whether it’s a roof fix on a youth centre, a fresh coat of paint on a park fence or new seating at an ice rink.

We created a name that connected to the brand’s purpose – and didn’t overpromise on the campaign’s proceeds – but instead, inspired their audience to think of relatable places in their community that could use a helping hand.

To gain awareness for the initiative, we created an explainer video showcasing their drive to transform community spaces across Manitoba and Saskatchewan in order to preserve them for generations to come. The animated video featured alliterative expressions of transformation, sharing examples of “makeover” stories – including the hammers, paint brushes and drills needed to complete them. It captured the authentic promise – and no more or less – to award up to $40,000 to communities for restoration projects.

Photo of a Red River Mutual magazine ad.

What Happened Next?

The campaign launched in early 2020 with radio spots and ads on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and Google. We also built many insurance broker assets they could use to co-promote the initiative in their communities and brokerages, as it is insurance brokers, and not Red River Mutual directly, who sells their products to the public.

A month into the campaign, the global COVID-19 pandemic hit. Because some of the messaging was centred around sprucing up gathering spaces during a time when gatherings were prohibited, we quickly reworked some of the messaging and had to remove the promise to commit volunteer hours to the final projects.

The campaign was a big success, proving that their promise to protect the places where people connect, laugh, learn and share – even during the height of the pandemic shutdown – connected.

During the three-and-a-half-month campaign, the video garnered 5.8 million impressions across all platforms and resulted in over 150 community “spruce up” submissions. In August, Red River Mutual announced 10 winning submissions – that would now split a $150,000 prize pool, thanks to the campaign’s overwhelming response.

Marketing Tips for In-House and Agency Teams

How can you face marketing challenges, both known and unexpected?

  1. Acknowledge your limitations and work within them. When there are companies out there committing millions to community projects, you have to acknowledge where you’re coming from, and what kind of projects you can and can’t support. There will still be a captive audience for what you’re offering – free money is free money –  just don’t try to stack up against the mega giveaways and instead, lean into your differentiator.
  2. Make content inspire visuals and visuals inspire content. Effective marketing needs to tell a story. Content and visuals go hand-in-hand when connecting to your audience. Bring those responsible for visuals into the brainstorming conversation early. Phrases like “wrecked to renewed” are nothing without their unique script treatment and paint brush swipes to convey their meaning.
  3. Don’t abandon everything at the first sign of trouble. Almost every marketing campaign runs into challenges—some are bigger than others. (Although not every challenge is as big as a global pandemic!) It’s easy to throw up your hands when something goes wrong but keep your larger purpose in mind and figure out the best way to move forward.

Recent Posts

  • December 1, 2023

    Creative Crushes: Kendra and Hayley Penner Part 1

    This month we’ve got crushes so nice, we’re writing about them twice! Kendra Penner, a photographer, and Hayley Penner, a songwriter and author, are two talented sisters with a famous father named Fred. We sat down with the pair to [...]

  • November 15, 2023

    What Sound Does a Brand Make?

    What sound does a brand make? This is the question that’s been nagging me for weeks—not because I’m grappling with the answer, but because it’s a question I should have started asking myself years ago. I recently attended a [...]

  • November 2, 2023

    Why Barbie Made Fun of Herself (and You Should Too)

    There are obviously about a trillion things to covet about the marketing of the Barbie movie: the partnerships, the music, the art direction, the hype machine that launched it… the list goes on. But maybe one of the [...]